Isisekelo solwazi Qala lapha
Iqhathaniswa kanjani iNymchat
I-Nymchat ilinganiswe nezinye izithunywa eziyishumi nantathu, ezintweni empeleni yehluka phakathi kwabo. Lapho oncintisana naye engcono, leli khasi lisho njalo - isiqhathaniso lokho kunombhali wayo owina yonke imigqa akusona isiqhathaniso.
Leli khasi lihunyushwe ngomshini ukuze kube lula. IsiNgisi sangempela inguqulo esebenzayo.
Kuhlolwe kuqhathaniswa nemibhalo yephrojekthi ngayinye ngo-Agasti 2026. Zonke lezi zinhlelo zokusebenza ziyathunyelwa ngokuvamile, futhi eminingana yemigqa engezansi iwuhlobo lwento olushintshayo kokuthi a khulula. Uma umugqa othile uthwala umthwalo wesinqumo sakho, iqinisekise ngokumelene ne- iphrojekthi ngokwayo ngaphambi kokuba uthembele kuyo.
Ngokuthi shazi
Ukubethela kuyiziteki zetafula kuleli khasi: cishe yonke into lapha ikwenza ngokuzenzakalelayo, futhi I-Nymchat ihamba phambili kuneningi - ayikho inombolo yocingo, ayikho i-akhawunti, futhi isipho esongwe imilayezo leyo okudluliselwa kuyo abangakwazi ukuyifunda noma ukuyichaza. Lapho insimu empeleni ukuhlukana kuyinto kwenzekani uma ingqalasizinda ihamba. Cishe sonke isithunywa esibetheliwe esaziwayo sima sifile ngaphandle kwe-inthanethi, ngenxa yokuphepha kwaso imodeli ithatha iseva engafinyelela kuyo. Idlanzana eliqhubeka nokusebenza ngaphandle komuntu linalo ngokomlando ikhokhelwe yona ngokuba ingcosana kakhulu ezicini.
Ukuhlela inkundla kuleyo mibuzo emibili - ukuthi uthola esingakanani isithunywa, nokuthi ngabe singakanani isinda kunethiwekhi ishona phansi - ishiya ikhona elilodwa cishe lingenalutho:
Yenza konke, kodwa kuphela ngenkathi i-inthanethi ivuliwe
- Isiginali
- I-Telegram
- Isici
Yonke into oyilindele kuhlelo lokusebenza lwengxoxo, ilethwe amaseva womuntu. Sika uxhumano futhi zonke zazo azinalutho isikrini.
Yenza konke, futhi usinde igridi ishona phansi
- Nymchat
Izingxoxo zeqembu ezibethelwe, izingcingo, imidiya nezinkokhelo uma kukhona iyinethiwekhi, kanye ne-Bluetooth mesh ngaphansi uma ingekho — njenge untanga ogcwele ku-Android ne-iOS, nanjengeqabunga kuziphequluli ze-Chromium.
Igxilile, futhi isadinga i-inthanethi
- I-SimpleX
- Iseshini
- Delta Chat
- XChat
- I-Vector
- Umsindo Omhlophe
Zonke lezi zihlanganisa okungenani into eyodwa ku-liste ngezansi - ngokuvamile izivakashi ze-group, ngezinye izikhathi i-platform. Ezinye zihlanganisa ezinhle; engapheliyo zihlanganisa ukuba abe konke okungenani.
Igxilile, futhi isinda kugridi iye phansi
- I-Armada
- Briar
- Bitchat
Ngayinye yinhle kakhulu kulokho ekwenzayo, futhi akukho eyakhelwe ukuba yikho okuwukuphela kohlelo lokusebenza ocingweni lwakho. I-Briar ne-Bitchat ayinazo izingcingo; U-Armada unamakholi kodwa akukho ukwakhiwa kwe-iOS, futhi i-mesh yayo isebenza ku-Android kuphela.
I-"Does everything" lapha inikeza inethiwekhi elifanayo enokutholakalayo: i-chats ye-group encrypted, i-one-to-one kanye ne-group audio/video calls, i-media sharing, kanye ne-app ye-native ku-Android ne-iOS - ibha ye-imeyile enokutholakalayo njenge-messenger yakho eyodwa. "I-Focused" inikeza inethiwekhi ibheka okungenani le-one of those, okuyinto isithombe, futhi akuyona isifinyezo. "I-Survives the grid going down" inikeza ama-messages enikeza phakathi kwizixhobo ngaphandle kwe-internet futhi akukho inkonzo ye-cell.
Yilokho konke, futhi lonke leli khasi liwubufakazi balo. I-Nymchat ayikho isithunywa esiyimfihlo kakhulu esake sakhiwa - i-SimpleX inesimangalo esinamandla kulokho, Okumhlophe Umsindo une-cryptography yeqembu engcono, futhi I-Signal ineminyaka yokucwaninga i-Nymchat ayinakho. I isimangalo sincane: yiyona yodwa yalezi esula leyo bha futhi isasebenza nini inethiwekhi ayisekho.
Ubunikazi ngenye ingxenye yakho. Okuzenzakalelayo kwe-Nymchat yi-nym eyenziwe lapho uvula uhlelo lokusebenza futhi ulahlwe uma usuqedile, nge Imodi yesipoki ukuzungezisa okhiye negama le-Bluetooth ndawonye nemiyalezo ezisusa yona ngemuva wena. Iningi lalolu hlu likunikeza i-akhawunti eyodwa ekulandelayo phakathi kwamagumbi naphakathi iminyaka. I-Nymchat ikuvumela ukuthi usho okuthile esixukwini ngaphandle kokuthi ikulandele ekhaya.
Izithunywa kulesi siqhathaniso
Izimbangi eziyishumi nantathu, ezikhethwe ngoba ngamunye muhle ngempela kokuthile uNymchat okufanele akwenze impendulo ye. Ukuduma kukodwa bekungeyona inkomba - ukube bekunjalo, lolu hlu beluzoba izinhlelo zokusebenza ezintathu ezinde nezingasebenziseki kangako.
| Uhlelo lokusebenza | Kuyini | Ingxabano yayo engcono kakhulu |
|---|---|---|
| Nymchat | Iklayenti le-Nostr elinemeshi ye-Bluetooth ngaphansi | Isithunywa esiphelele esingami lapho inethiwekhi ima |
| Briar | Isigijimi sontanga phezu kwe-Tor, i-Bluetooth, i-Wi-Fi nezinti ze-USB | Awekho nhlobo amaseva, kanye nokuhlolwa kokuphepha okuzimele okuzokhonjwa kukho |
| I-Armada | Imiphakathi ebethelwe yesitayela se-Discord ku-Nostr, kusukela ku-Soapbox | I-Bitchat's mesh ngaphakathi kohlelo lokusebenza lomphakathi olugcwele, nokuzibamba ngokwakho kuze kube phansi |
| Bitchat | Ingxoxo ye-Bluetooth ye-mesh eneziteshi ze-Nostr ezivaliwe | Ukuvezwa okumsulwa kokulayeza kwe-mesh, kuhlolwe ngesikhathi sokuvalwa kwangempela |
| Delta Chat | Isithunywa esigibela i-imeyili, esinama-akhawunti e-chatmail alahlwayo | Isebenza nengqalasizinda esivele ikhona yonke indawo futhi engeke ivalwe |
| Isici | Iklayenti eliphambili lenethiwekhi ye-Matrix ehlanganisiwe | Inhlangano esebenza ngempela, futhi ihlanganisa cishe yonke enye into |
| Iseshini | Isigijimi esiqondiswe ku-anyanisi phezu kwenethiwekhi ye-node ehlukanisiwe | Ayikho inombolo yocingo, futhi ikheli lakho le-IP lifihliwe kubantu okhuluma nabo |
| Isiginali | Isithunywa esibethelwe esisingathwa endaweni emaphakathi, ephethwe inhlangano engenzi nzuzo | I-cryptography ebuyekezwe kakhulu ebhizinisini, kanye nephrothokholi ekopishwe wonke umuntu |
| I-SimpleX Chat | Isilayezi sakhelwe kulayini wemilayezo yesikhathi esisodwa esikhundleni sama-akhawunti omsebenzisi | Azikho izihlonzi zabasebenzisi zanoma yiluphi uhlobo — indaba yemethadatha enamandla kakhulu lapha |
| I-Telegram | Isithunywa samafu esinamaqembu amakhulu kakhulu namashaneli | Finyelela, upholisha, ama-bot, nemiphakathi ngezinkulungwane ezingamakhulu |
| I-Vector | Isithunywa esiyimfihlo sika-Nostr esine-AI ekudivayisi kanye nesikhwama semali esakhelwe ngaphakathi | Ukuloba nokuhumusha okusebenza emshinini wakho esikhundleni seseva |
| Isithunywa se-Meta, esibethelwe ekupheleni ukuya ekupheleni ngokuzenzakalela | Wonke umuntu omaziyo usenayo | |
| XChat | Iqembu le-0xchat libhale kabusha iqembu le-MLS elithi "Imibuthano" | Isithunywa se-Nostr esisungulwe kakhulu, kanye nokubethela kweqembu le-MLS kuhlelo lokusebenza lokuthumela |
| Umsindo Omhlophe | I-Nostr messenger eyakhelwe ku-MLS, izinga lokuthumela imiyalezo leqembu le-IETF | I-cryptography yeqembu eqine kakhulu ku-Nostr, futhi kusesekuseni - kuseyi-alpha |
Uhlelo lokusebenza kulolu hlu oluseduzane ne-Nymchat Bitchat, futhi akusondeli phakathi abaphume isibili. Laba bobabili babelana nge-Bluetooth mesh, babelana ngeziteshi ze-geohash, futhi bona ahlanganiswe ezingeni lephrothokholi - umsebenzisi we-Bitchat kanye nomsebenzisi weNymchat ngokufanayo I-geohash isendlini eyodwa, ifunda imilayezo yomunye nomunye, alukho uhlelo lokusebenza olwenza lutho ekhethekile. Akukho okunye lapha okunobudlelwano noNymchat. Izithunywa zeNostr — XChat, Vector, Armada, White Noise — yabelana ngenethiwekhi kanye nomlayezo oyimfihlo ifomethi, okuwenza abe isiqhathaniso esiseduze sama-DM nama-zaps abethelwe, kodwa awekho kuwo anezikhala futhi alikho elinamagumbi anendawo.
Izinhlelo zokusebenza ezimbili ezingahlobene zibizwa nge-XChat. Lena elapha ivela kuphrojekthi ye-Nostr 0xchat — hhayi isithunywa sika-X sika igama elifanayo, elethulwe ngo-Ephreli 2026 futhi alihlanganyeli lutho nalo ngaphandle kwegama. Lapho umugqa uthi "Ku-0xchat", isici sithunyelwa ngohlelo lokusebenza oludala lwe-0xchat kanye nelomdabu. ukubhala kabusha kusaqhuba.
Isici ngesici
Amathebula amahlanu, aqoqwe ngombuzo ngalinye liphendula. Yonke ikholomu ibhalwe ukuthi Yebo impendulo enhle - ayikho imigqa lapho iseli eluhlaza kuyizindaba ezimbi. I amathebula apheqa emaceleni esikrinini esincane, futhi igama lohlelo lokusebenza lihlala libekiwe ngenkathi benza.
Ukungena
| Ukungena | Ayikho inombolo yocingo | Ayikho i-akhawunti yeseva | Ubunikazi buwukhiye kudivayisi yakho | Vula kubantu ongabazi | Ubunikazi bokulahla |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nymchat | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo |
| I-Armada | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Emiphakathini yomphakathi | Cha |
| Bitchat | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | I-Ephemeral ngokuzenzakalelayo |
| Briar | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | Cha |
| Delta Chat | Yebo | Kudalelwe wena | Cha | Cha | Ikheli elahlwayo |
| Isici | Yebo | Cha | Cha | Emakamelweni omphakathi | Cha |
| Iseshini | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Emaqenjini avulekile | Cha |
| Isiginali | Cha | Cha | Cha | Cha | Cha |
| I-SimpleX | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Ngesixhumanisi sokumema | Imodi ye-Incognito |
| I-Telegram | Cha | Cha | Cha | Emaqenjini omphakathi | Cha |
| I-Vector | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Cha |
| Cha | Cha | Cha | Cha | Cha | |
| Umsindo Omhlophe | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Cha |
| I-XChat (0xchat) | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Cha |
Isiginali, iTelegramu kanye ne-WhatsApp konke kuhlanganisa i-akhawunti yakho enombolweni yocingo, okuyinto ngokuvamile amazwe kusho ukuyibophezela kumazisi kahulumeni. Isignali yenze okungaphezu kwanoma ubani ukukhawulela umonakalo - amagama omsebenzisi asho ukuthi awulokothi unikeze inombolo koxhumana naye, futhi ifihlwa ngu okuzenzakalelayo — kodwa ukubhalisa kusadinga inombolo esebenzayo, futhi leyo nombolo iyona i-akhawunti.
"Vula abantu ongabazi" umugqa ohlukanisa inethiwekhi yomphakathi encwadini yamakheli. Briar, I-SimpleX kanye ne-Delta Chat zonke zidinga ukuthi nishintshe okuthile kuqala — ikhodi ye-QR, a isixhumanisi, ikheli — elilungele ubumfihlo futhi elingenamsebenzi wokungena ekamelweni nokuthola ukuthi kwenzekani. I-Nymchat's ephemeral nym iyibhangqa elingukhiye elakhiwe ngaleso sikhathi uvula uhlelo lokusebenza; bona I-Ephemeral Identities, futhi Imodi yesipoki ngenguqulo ejikelezayo nayo ishintsha lokho okukhangiswa ngumsakazo wakho we-Bluetooth.
Ukuhlala phezulu
| Inethiwekhi | Isebenza ngaphandle kwe-inthanethi | Iziteshi zomphakathi | Iziteshi ziboshelwe endaweni | Ukhetha amaseva | Idlula abenzi bayo |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nymchat | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo |
| I-Armada | I-Android kuphela | Yebo | Cha | Yebo | Yebo |
| Bitchat | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo |
| Briar | Yebo | Cha | Cha | Awekho nhlobo amaseva | Yebo |
| Delta Chat | Cha | Sakaza kuphela | Cha | Yebo | Yebo |
| Isici | Cha | Yebo | Cha | Yebo | Yebo |
| Iseshini | Cha | Yebo | Cha | Inethiwekhi ye-Node | Cishe |
| Isiginali | Cha | Cha | Cha | Cha | Cha |
| I-SimpleX | Cha | Ngesixhumanisi sokumema | Cha | Yebo | Yebo |
| I-Telegram | Cha | Yebo | Cha | Cha | Cha |
| I-Vector | Cha | Cha | Cha | Yebo | Yebo |
| Cha | Sakaza kuphela | Cha | Cha | Cha | |
| Umsindo Omhlophe | Cha | Cha | Cha | Yebo | Yebo |
| I-XChat (0xchat) | Cha | Yebo | Cha | Yebo | Yebo |
Leli yithebula iNymchat ekhona, futhi ezinye izinhlelo zokusebenza ezintathu ziyaliphendula. UBriar uyathwala imiyalezo nge-Bluetooth, i-Wi-Fi nezinti ze-USB. I-Bitchat iyimeshi ye-Bluetooth kuqala futhi konke okunye okwesibili. I-Armada ithumela isitaki se-Bitchat se-Android se-mesh ngaphakathi kohlelo lwayo lokusebenza, sivuliwe Android.
I-Nymchat yabelana ngefomethi yayo ye-mesh ne-Bitchat ngenhloso: lezi zinhlelo zokusebenza ezimbili zijoyina amagumbi afanayo futhi edlulisela komunye nomunye, okwenza inethiwekhi engaxhunyiwe ku-inthanethi ibe nkulu kukho kokubili. Isebenza ku-Android kanye ne-iOS njengontanga egcwele, futhi kuziphequluli ze-Chromium njengeqabunga elingathola futhi lithumele kodwa hhayi zikhangise. Bheka Yabelana nge-Bitchat futhi Igijima kuphi.
Ikholomu yokugcina kufanele ifundwe ngokucophelela. Isignali iyinhlangano engenzi nzuzo enerekhodi elihle futhi cha inhloso yokuya noma yikuphi, kodwa Isignali ngaphandle kwamaseva eSiginali ayilutho nhlobo. Nostr ama-relay, ama-homeservers e-Matrix, ukudluliselwa kwe-SimpleX kanye namaseva ajwayelekile e-imeyili wonke ama-software noma ubani ingasebenza, ngakho-ke "inhlangano iyavala" futhi "inethiwekhi iyafa" imicimbi ehlukene. I-Delta I-Chat inenguqulo eqine kakhulu yale mpikiswano ohlwini: igibele nge-imeyili, engenjalo ukuya noma yikuphi.
Okubonwa yinethiwekhi
| Ubumfihlo | Imilayezo eyimfihlo ibethelwe ngokuzenzakalelayo | Izingxoxo zeqembu zibethelwe | Phambili imfihlo | Ukushintshanisa ukhiye we-Post-quantum | Umthumeli nomamukeli ufihliwe | Imilayezo enyamalalayo | Ukucwaningwa kwamabhuku okuzimele kushicilelwe |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nymchat | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | I-ML-KEM-768 | I-Group; PMs inikeza kuphela | Yebo | Hhayi okwamanje |
| I-Armada | Yebo | Concord | Akushiwo | Cha | Thumela kuphela | Cha | Cha |
| Bitchat | Yebo | Iziteshi zisesidlangalaleni | Yebo | Cha | Ngokwengxenye | Yebo | Cha |
| Briar | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | Yebo | Cha | Yebo |
| Delta Chat | Yebo | Yebo | Ukubethela okuzenzakalelayo v2 | Cha | Ngokwengxenye | Yebo | Yebo |
| Isici | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | Cha | Igumbi ngalinye | Yebo |
| Iseshini | Yebo | Yebo | Kususiwe | Cha | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo |
| Isiginali | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | I-PQXDH | Umthumeli ovaliwe | Yebo | Yebo |
| I-SimpleX | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Isiqephu 761 | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo |
| I-Telegram | Izingxoxo eziyimfihlo kuphela | Cha | Izingxoxo eziyimfihlo kuphela | Cha | Cha | Yebo | Cha |
| I-Vector | Yebo | Imiphakathi iyaqhubeka | Akushiwo | Cha | Thumela kuphela | Cha | Cha |
| Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | Cha | Yebo | Umthombo ovaliwe | |
| Umsindo Omhlophe | Yebo | I-MLS | I-MLS | Cha | Yebo | Cha | Yebo |
| I-XChat (0xchat) | Yebo | I-MLS | I-MLS | Cha | Thumela kuphela | Cha | Cha |
I-post-quantum ye-column iyiphi ingozi elilodwa: umugqa we-adversary ihlolwe i-traffic e-encrypted namhlanje ukuze ihlolwe iminyaka embalwa, uma i-computer ye-quantum angakwazi ukuhlangabezana ne-classical key agreement zonke izicelo lapha zihlanganisa. Akukho okuvimbela ingozi kusuka kumadokhumenti enokufundisa manje, futhi akuyona akuyona ingozi - kuphela ngenxa yobuchwepheshe. Amaphrozi ezintathu kulesi isithombe isizinda, futhi zonke amaphrozi zihlanganisa i-post-quantum key encapsulation ku-classical exchange ukuze ukuhlangabezana ingozi kuyinto ukuhlangabezana kokubiliI-Signal - okokuqala, nge-PQXDH, futhi emva kwalokho ifakwe nge-post-quantum ratchet - futhi i-SimpleX, nge-sntrup761 e-double ratchet yayo, Ukuhlobisa izibambiso ezimbili ezahlukile ku-key eyodwa. Nymchat Ukuhlobisa Ngaphandle kwalokho: Umbhali we-NIP-44 iyatholakala ngokufanayo futhi igcinwe okwesibili ngaphakathi kwe-ChaCha20-Poly1305, eyenziwe nge-encapsulation ye-ML-KEM-768 - i-NIST standard, i-FIPS 203. Ukuhlanganiswa kuyadingeka ukufinyelela okuzenzakalelayo kwe-exchange yokuqala, okuyinto isixazululo se-browser noma i-remote signer ayikwazi ukufinyelela, ngakho-ke i-layering kuyinto okuvumela ama-logins zihlanganisa. Funda kabanzi Ukubethela kwe-post-quantum. Lena ikholomu ezoguga ngokushesha, futhi elithi "Cha" lapha lisho "okungathunyelwanga kusukela kulokhu kubhalwa", hhayi "akukaze".
Izinhlayiya ezine zihlanganisa ngaphezulu kuka-cell, futhi yokuqala kunezinhlayiya kuyinto ye-Nymchat.
I-Nymchat Ayikho I-Future SecretI-NIP-44 ikhiqiza ikhwalithi yayo kusuka kumakhwalithi amabili ye-identity, futhi ikhwalithi ye-ML-KEM esithathwe ku-post-quantum layer kuyinto elide kakhulu, ngakho-ke wonke umntu owafakiwe ngemva nsec
Ukubuyekezwa nympq1… ikhowudi, ngenxa ye-post-quantum layer — ungazifunda wonke umbhalo ebhalwe ama-keys eyakhiwe, akuyona kuphela ama-keys ezidlulile. I-setting ebizwa ngokuthi Inyamalala PM (dlulisela phambili imfihlo) in I-Privacy & Security iyisisombululo se-NIP-40 yokushicilela ebizwa ukuthi ama-relayers abalandela umbhalo ngokushesha; lokhu kuyinto i-disappearing-messages ye-column, akuyona lokhu. I-Telegram Ukubhalisa isikhwama end-to-end ngaphandle kokufaka ngokuvamile i-Secret Chat, okuyinto i-one-to-one kuphela futhi akufanele ukuxhumana phakathi kwezixhobo zakho - ngoko ngokuvamile zonke izivumelwano ze-Telegram, futhi
zonke Iqembu leTelegramu, lihlala lifundeka kumaseva eTelegramu.
Iseshini ilahle ngamabomu imfihlo lapho isuka kuSignal
umthetho olandelwayo, okusho ukuthi ukhiye wesikhathi eside owebiwe udalula umlando wonke kunewakamuva nje embalwa
imiyalezo; iphrojekthi ithe inguqulo yephrothokholi yesikhathi esizayo izoyibuyisa.
Delta Chat ithola ifa lokuntula i-OpenPGP yezimfihlo zangaphambili, futhi uthe
Ukubethela okuzenzakalelayo v2 kuzokulungisa.
I-metadata ye-column ifakwe, ngenxa ye-Nymchat, phakathi kwezinhlobo ezimbini zokusabela. Yonke i-cadew wrap iyathunyelwa nge-throwable key, ngakho-ke i-relay ayikwazi ukwazi ukuthi Thumela 1. Yintoni eyahlukile i-receiver. I-wrap ifakwe eyodwa ku-a p I-tag, ngokucacileyo, ngenxa yokuba le-tag yindlela yokufumana umbhali - kodwa
ikhaya Okuzenzakalelayo: I-tag ithatha ikhoyili wokuguqulwa ye-per-member kunokuba ikhoyili ye-real ye-member, ngakho-ke umbhali we-group akuyona njenge-N wraps ku-N pubkeys ngexesha elifanayo futhi i-relay akufundisa akugqoka.
Ukubethela kweqembu kusebenza kanjaniUkubuyekezwa
Ukubuyekezwa Ukubuyekezwa kwe-conversation, akukho okuhlobisa: i-wrap ifakwe ku-peer's real key, ngakho-ke ama-relayers bakwazi ukufumana futhi cishe lapho.
Konke amakhasimende we-Nostr etholakalayo nge-NIP-17 gift wraps inesilinganiso esifanayo, okuyinto i-Armada, i-Vector ne-XChat ibheka i-"sender-only" futhi - i-rotating e-column ye-group iyona i-Nymchat, futhi akuyona i-protocol. I-White Noise ibheka ngezindlela ezahlukile: izindaba ze-MLS ziye zithunyelwa ku-per-group key kunazo zonke abalandeli. Futhi kuyinto ingxubevange e-SimpleX ayikho, eminye uhlobo le-conversation, ngoba inikeza inethiwekhi ayikho idivayisi yokuhlanganisa ekuqaleni.
Ikholomu yokugcina yileyo ehlulwe yiNymchat, futhi ayiphumelelanga kulo nyaka. UBriar ubelokhu ihlolwe yi-Cure53, i-SimpleX yi-Trail of Bits, i-White Noise yi-Least Authority ngo-Ephreli 2026, kanye ne-Signal, Matrix kanye ne-Delta Chat ngokuphindaphindiwe ngamafemu amaningana. I-Nymchat ayikenzi a ukuhlolwa komuntu wesithathu. Okukunikezayo kunalokho ukuthi yonke into ingumthombo ovulekile kanye ne- isakhiwo esithunyelwe siyakhiqizeka, ngakho-ke ungakwazi ukuhlola kanambambili uqhathanise nomthombo ngokwakho — bona Ukwakhiwa kabusha. Lokho akuyona a esikhundleni sokuhlolwa, futhi leli khasi ngeke lizenze sengathi linjalo.
I-Nymchat's iziteshi zomphakathi azibetheliwe, futhi akuzona ezikaBitchat. Yilowo mklamo - igumbi lomphakathi kuphela abanye abantu abangalifunda akulona igumbi lomphakathi — kodwa kusho ukuthi noma yini oyithumela esiteshini iwumcimbi osobala osesidlangalaleni amalayidi. Amakholomu angenhla amayelana nemilayezo eyimfihlo nezingxoxo zamaqembu. Bheka Izinhlobo ezimbili zesiteshi.
Ongakwenza empeleni
| Izici | Izingcingo zomuntu ngamunye | Izingcingo zeqembu | Izingxoxo zeqembu | Imidiya namafayela | Izinkokhelo zombani | Umsizi owakhelwe ngaphakathi | Humusha endaweni |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nymchat | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo |
| I-Armada | Yebo | Izikhumba zezwi | Yebo | Yebo | Akushiwo | Cha | Cha |
| Bitchat | Cha | Cha | Iziteshi zomphakathi | Izithombe namanothi ezwi | Cha | Cha | Cha |
| Briar | Cha | Cha | Yebo | Izithombe kuphela | Cha | Cha | Cha |
| Delta Chat | Yebo | Cha | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | Cha | Cha |
| Isici | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | Cha | Cha |
| Iseshini | Yebo | Cha | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | Cha | Cha |
| Isiginali | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | Cha | Cha |
| I-SimpleX | Yebo | Cha | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | Cha | Cha |
| I-Telegram | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | I-third party bots | Yebo |
| I-Vector | Cha | Cha | Imiphakathi iyaqhubeka | Yebo | I-Wallet eyakhelwe ngaphakathi | Kudivayisi | Kudivayisi |
| Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | I-Meta AI | Yebo | |
| Umsindo Omhlophe | Cha | Cha | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | Cha | Cha |
| I-XChat (0xchat) | Ku-0xchat | Cha | Yebo | Yebo | Ku-0xchat | Cha | Cha |
I-Briar, i-Bitchat, iVector kanye Noise Olumhlophe yilapho ingxenye "egxilile" yesakhiwo iza khona kusukela, futhi umugqa ozibeka lapho kukhona ikholomu yezingcingo: akukho noyedwa kwabane ozobeka a ikholi yezwi noma yevidiyo. Akukhona ukushoda kwezici kwenye indawo. I-Bitchat manje ithwala izithombe ezibethelwe namanothi ezwi phezu kwe-mesh ngokwayo - inkinga enzima kunayo izwakala kurediyo enensayo, eyabelwene, esebenza ngebhethri, kanye negebe elimelene ne-Nymchat enalo ivaliwe.
Ingxoxo ebukhoma iyona esele. Ucingo ludinga indlela eyi-duplex ene-latency ephansi, okuthi a I-multi-hop Bluetooth mesh ayikwazi ukukunika, ngakho i-Nymchat iphatha amakholi ngenethiwekhi futhi iwela emuva kumbhalo kanye nemeshi uma ingekho. Lowo umehluko phakathi kohlelo lokusebenza lokho kugcina kusebenza ekucinyweni kukagesi futhi ongayisebenzisa ngoLwesibili.
Ikholomu yomsizi idinga i-caveat ekhomba kude ne-Nymchat. I-Meta AI ingumsizi wangempela yakhelwe ku-WhatsApp, kanye nokugijima kweVector kudivayisi yakho siqu - Ukuhleba okulotshiweyo nokuhumusha endaweni, okuyindaba yobumfihlo yangempela kune I-Nymbot's. Lokho uNymbot akunikeza kona esikhundleni umsizi ongawusebenzisa esiteshini somphakathi ngaphandle kokuziveza, engxoxweni yangasese eyisipho esigoqwe njengazo zonke ezinye ingxoxo. Bheka Ingxoxo yangasese - futhi inothi ukuthi u-opharetha we-bot usengakwazi ukufunda lokho okuthumelayo, okuyiqiniso kuwo wonke ama-server-side umsizi kulolu hlu.
Lapho igijima, futhi ubani ogijimayo
| Amapulatifomu | Android | iOS | Ideskithophu noma isiphequluli | Iyafakeka ngaphandle kwesitolo sohlelo lokusebenza | Iqalisa ikhophi oyisingathile ngokwakho | Umthombo ovulekile | Awekho amasevisi e-Google adingekayo |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nymchat | Yebo | TestFlight | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo |
| I-Armada | Yebo | Isiphequluli kuphela | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo |
| Bitchat | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | I-Android kuphela | Cha | Yebo | Yebo |
| Briar | Yebo | Cha | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | Yebo | Yebo |
| Delta Chat | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | Yebo | Yebo |
| Isici | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo |
| Iseshini | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | I-Android kuphela | Cha | Yebo | Yebo |
| Isiginali | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | I-Android kuphela | Cha | Yebo | Yebo |
| I-SimpleX | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | I-Android kuphela | Cha | Yebo | Yebo |
| I-Telegram | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | I-Android kuphela | Amaseva weTelegram kuphela | Iklayenti kuphela | Cha |
| I-Vector | Yebo | Cha | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | Yebo | Yebo |
| Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | Cha | Cha | Cha | |
| Umsindo Omhlophe | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Yebo | Cha | Yebo | Yebo |
| I-XChat (0xchat) | Yebo | Yebo | Ku-0xchat | Yebo | Cha | Yebo | Yebo |
Isakhiwo se-iOS sikaNymchat siku-TestFlight kune-App Store, ethembekile "ngokwengxenye" - ifaka kunoma iyiphi i-iPhone, kodwa ngesiteshi se-beta se-Apple. Briar futhi I-Vector ayinayo i-iOS yokwakha nhlobo, futhi uBriar usho ukuthi kungani ngokusobala: I-iOS ngeke ivumele isizinda inqubo igcina ukuxhumana kontanga kuya kontanga kuphila ngendlela edingwa ngayo isakhiwo sayo. I-Nymchat ingena inguqulo ethambile yodonga olufanayo, yingakho izaziso ze-iOS zifika sekwephuzile ngenkathi uhlelo lokusebenza imisiwe. Bheka Igijima kuphi.
Ikholomu okufanele kumiswe kuyo yileyo emayelana nokubamba ikhophi yakho, ngoba ichaza ukuthi ngempela isithunywa sifa kanjani ezweni. Hhayi i-cryptanalysis - ukususa ohlwini. I-Apple ne-Google iyiphuzu elilodwa lokuminyanisa, ohulumeni bayakwazi, futhi uhlelo lokusebenza lususiwe kukho kokubili izitolo ziphelile cishe kuwo wonke umuntu obeyisebenzisa.
Uhlelo lokusebenza lwewebhu lweNymchat lungamamojula e-HTML, CSS kanye neJavaScript engenalutho asikho isinyathelo sokwakha. Ikhonze kunoma yimuphi umsingathi omile, i-USB stick noma i-hosthost futhi iwuhlelo lokusebenza lonke - umthetho olandelwayo ofanayo, ukudluliselwa okufanayo, inethiwekhi efanayo njengoba ifoni yakha, iyafakeka esikrinini sasekhaya kusuka kusiphequluli. Akukho lutho vumela futhi akukho lutho oluzokwehliswa. Isizinda singavinjwa; ifayela elinezinkulungwane zabantu esezivele zikhona azikwazi ukuyekiswa ukushicilelwa.
Abanye ababili bangakwenza lokhu, futhi bobabili bafanelwe udumo. I-Element Web ibilokhu ikhona ikwazi ukuzibamba, futhi i-Armada iya kude kakhulu kunanoma ubani lapha - ibhala ukuthi iqhutshwa kanjani uhlelo lokusebenza lwewebhu, ukudluliselwa komphakathi kanye neseva yezwi ngokwakho. Abayishumi nanye abasele abakwazi: Isiginali, Iseshini, iSimpleX, iBriar, iDelta Chat, iVector, iWhite Noise, iBitchat neXChat kukhona izinhlelo zokusebenza zomdabu ezingenazo isiphequluli esakhiwe, iklayenti lewebhu leTelegram likhuluma neTelegram kuphela, kanye ne-WhatsApp Web idinga ifoni ukuze ihambisane nayo.
Lokhu kufanelekile ukunemba ngakho kunokwengamela. Ikhophi ozibambele yona ye iklayenti lisadinga ukudluliswa ukuze lifinyelele noma ubani ngale kwebanga le-Bluetooth — kodwa ukudluliselwa yikho futhi isofthiwe noma ubani angasebenza, kukhona amakhulukhulu asesidlangalaleni, futhi i-Nymchat ikuvumela khomba noma yini oyithandayo. Iklayenti kanye nenethiwekhi kufanele kuhlolwe ngokwehlukana, futhi akekho nomnikazi onganikeza kuye i-oda.
Okwenziwa nguNymchat kuphela
Into eyodwa ayikho enye into lapha, kanye nezine ezabiwa nedlanzana lezinye izinhlelo zokusebenza.
- I-mesh kuyo yonke inkundla ethunyelwa kuyo. U-Briar no-Bitchat bobabili bayadluliselana ngaphandle kwengqalasizinda, futhi i-Bitchat manje iphethe izithombe nayo - kodwa futhi uzofaka ucingo. I-Nymchat ukuphela kohlelo lokusebenza lapha lapho imodi yokungaxhunyiwe ku-inthanethi iyibuyisela emuva ngaphakathi kwesithunywa esiphelele kunomkhiqizo wonke, futhi ihlangana njengentanga egcwele ku-Android ne-iOS nanjengeqabunga kuziphequluli ze-Chromium. Ukucima kukagesi akuhloli ukuthi iyiphi ifoni oyithengile.
- Amagumbi omphakathi abhekiswa ngendawo. Isiteshi se-geohash sivula noma yisiphi isikwele Umhlaba ungene engosini yengevu engadingi mnikazi, umongameli noma isimemo — wonke umuntu odivayisi yakhe exazulula leso sikwele usevele ukuso. I-Bitchat inalokhu futhi, futhi lezi zinhlelo zokusebenza ezimbili zabelana ngamagumbi. Akekho omunye onento efana nayo. Bheka Iziteshi ze-Geohash.
- Imali ehamba engxoxweni. Umbani udlalisa umlayezo noma iphrofayili, exazulule untanga ukuze ulunguze ngemizuzwana ngengxenye yesenti. Lokhu akuyona a I-Nymchat ikhethekile ku-Nostr - I-XChat ine-zaps futhi i-Vector ithumela isikhwama semali - kodwa ikuyo yonke indawo kulolu hlu, futhi iNymchat ukuphela kohlelo lokusebenza enalo eceleni kwe- Imeshi. Bheka Ithumela i-zap.
- Ukubethela kwe-Post-quantum ku-Nostr. I-Nymchat ye-private message kanye ne-group chats ivula i-NIP-44 ye-ciphertext ebonakalayo ngaphakathi kwe-second, i-ML-KEM-768 layer, ngakho-ke i-traffic ebonakalayo namhlanje ayikwazi ukucacisa nge-computer ye-quantum. Lokhu akuyona i-Nymchat yokufinyelela - I-Signal ne-SimpleX waya lapho kuqala, futhi wabhala ngokushesha - kodwa ku-Nostr i-Nymchat kuphela. I-XChat, i-Vector, i-Armada, i-White Noise kanye naminye ama-Nostr amakhasimende apha i-encrypted nge-secp256k1 nokuningi. Akukho ukulawula nokuhlanganiswa kwe-keyodwa Ukubethela kwe-post-quantum.
- Izingxoxo zeqembu ezifihla ubulungu bawo. Ukugoqa izipho ezijwayelekile ivuza uhlu lwamalungu - N ukusonga ku-N pubkeys ngesikhathi esifanayo kuwukuxhumana nabantu igrafu nakuba kungekho okususa ukubethela. I-Nymchat izungezisa okhiye bomamukeli ukuze leyo phethini yenze hhayi ifomu. I-White Noise ne-XChat zifinyelela endaweni efanayo nge-MLS esikhundleni salokho; abathathu kithina sodwa kulolu hlu ngokuba nalo nhlobo. Bheka Ukubethela kweqembu kusebenza kanjani.
Lapho abanye benamandla khona
Konke kwalokhu kuyisizathu sangempela sokukhetha enye into, futhi akukho neyodwa yazo ezoba khona saxabana lapha.
| Uhlelo lokusebenza | Yini eyenza kangcono |
|---|---|
| Isiginali | I-Cryptography eyenziwe ngama-professional iminyaka eminyakeni futhi eyenziwe, kuhlanganise i-ratchet ezimbini - ngoku post-quantum - okuvumela ukubuyekezwa kwe-Nymchat ayikho. Uma imodeli yakho ye-threat is a state actor and you want the most reviewed thing available, it’s still Signal, and it’s not close. |
| I-SimpleX | Indaba engcono kakhulu yemethadatha kune-Nymchat. I-Nymchat ikunikeza ukhiye ongaziwa; I-SimpleX ayinikezi inethiwekhi isihlonzi ukuthi ihlobanise nakancane, ngisho a okungahleliwe. Uma ecashile ukuthi unengxoxo okubaluleke ngaphezu ekuqukethe, i-SimpleX iyawina. |
| Umsindo Omhlophe | I-cryptography yeqembu eqinile kune-Nymchat, kunethiwekhi efanayo. Kokubili izinhlelo zokusebenza ziyalulama ngemuva kokuthi idivayisi isengozini - I-Nymchat's okhiye bamamukeli abazungezisayo zinjalo impela leyo ndlela - kodwa i-MLS iyenza isiqinisekiso somthethonqubo. |
| I-Armada | Indaba enemininingwane yokuzenzela wena kulolu hlu: uhlelo lokusebenza lwewebhu, i ukudluliselwa komphakathi kanye neseva yezwi ye-LiveKit konke kubhalwe ukuthi kuqhubeke hardware yakho siqu. Iwuhlelo lokusebenza lwemiphakathi emise okwe-Discord kune-a isithunywa, futhi siphethe i-Bluetooth mesh ku-Android. |
| XChat | Ukugqagqana ne-Nymchat kukhulu kakhulu kulolu hlu - okhiye be-Nostr, zaps, amaqembu abethelwe - futhi yenza iqembu ingxenye nge-MLS kunalokho kunokuzungezisa izipho ezisongayo. Uma ufuna lokho okunikezwa yi-Nymchat ku-inthanethi futhi ungakwenzi ngidinga i-mesh, kuyimpi efanelekile. |
| Briar | Awekho amaseva noma kuphi ekwakhiweni, ngisho nalawo ozikhethela wona, kanye nashicilelwe Cure53 ukuhlolwa. I-Nymchat isafinyelela ukudluliselwa lapho i-inthanethi ikhona; UBriar akalokothi akwenze. |
| Bitchat | Okuncane, kulula futhi kulula ukucabanga ngakho. Izici ezimbalwa ziyisivikelo impahla, futhi ekuvaleleni kwangempela uhlelo lokusebenza oluhlutshiwe elenza into eyodwa kuyisinqumo esivikelekile. |
| Delta Chat | Igibela nge-imeyili, ngakho isebenza ngengqalasizinda esevele ikhona wonke amazwe nokuthi ayikho inkampani eyodwa engacisha. Akukho okunye lapha inenethiwekhi esunguliwe. |
| I-Vector | I-AI yayo isebenza kudivayisi yakho. Okulotshiweyo nokuhumusha akulokothi kushiye i- umshini, ongcono kakhulu kunokuwathumela eNymbot - futhi ifakazela ukuthi lesi sici asikho isidingo sokuthi sikubize ngobumfihlo. |
| Isici | Inhlangano enokuthunyelwa kwangempela ngemuva kwayo - ohulumeni kanye amanyuvesi asebenzisa ama-homeservers awo - kanye namabhuloho ku-IRC, Slack, I-Discord nokuningi. Uma udinga ukuba umnikazi weseva, lona okhulile inketho. |
| Iseshini | U-anyanisi uvula ngokuzenzakalelayo, ukuze ikheli lakho le-IP lifihlwe kunethiwekhi ngaphandle kokuthi ulungise noma yini. I-Nymchat ingakwenza lokhu ngokusebenzisa yayo ummeleli wobumfihlo, kodwa lokho kuyilungiselelo, futhi isilungiselelo yinto abantu abayikhohlwayo. |
| I-Telegram | Imiphakathi ngezinga elikhulu akukho okunye okusondelayo lapha, i-bot ecosystem nge iminyaka yokusebenza kuyo, kanye nolwazi olushelela kakhulu lwamadivayisi amaningi wanoma yiluphi uhlelo lokusebenza leli khasi. |
| Wonke umuntu usenayo. Isithunywa ekungekho muntu omaziyo ozosifaka sivikela lutho, futhi lelo akulona iphuzu elincane - yisona sizathu siphephe kakhulu izithunywa ziyehluleka. |
Yikuphi okufanele ukusebenzise
Thembeka: ngaphezu kokukodwa. Lezi zimahhala, futhi azibizi lutho ukugcina zifakiwe ngokumelene ne- usuku ozidingayo.
- Udinga i-cryptography ebuyekeziwe eqine kakhulu. Isiginali, bese ubeka i-Nymchat eceleni kwayo lapho inethiwekhi ihamba.
- Udinga inethiwekhi ukuze ungazi ukuthi ukhona. I-SimpleX.
- Usembhikishweni, emkhosini, enkundleni yezemidlalo, noma kwenye indawo lapho bekukhona i-inthanethi ukusika. I-Nymchat noma i-Bitchat, noma i-Armada uma wonke umuntu ekhona ku-Android - futhi akubalulekile kunalokho ongakucabanga, ngoba asebenzisa i-mesh efanayo.
- Ufuna uhlelo lokusebenza olulodwa lwengxoxo yansuku zonke nalo olusindayo ukucisha. I-Nymchat. Yileso sizathu sonke esikhona.
- Ufuna ukubethela kweqembu okuhle kakhulu ku-Nostr. White Noise, okuyinto manje inocwaningo lokuyisekela, noma i-XChat uma ungathanda ukuba nama-zaps namakholi ku- uhlelo lokusebenza olufanayo.
- Udinga ukuqhuba ingqalasizinda ngokwakho, ngaphansi kwenqubomgomo yakho. I-element nge-homeserver yakho, i-Armada ene-relay yakho neseva yezwi, noma i-Delta Xoxa neseva yakho yemeyili.
- Ulindele ukuthi uhlelo lokusebenza luvinjelwe lapho uhlala khona. I-Nymchat. Uhlelo lokusebenza lwewebhu iyifolda yamafayela engenasinyathelo sokwakha, ngakho igijima isuka kumsingathi omile, induku ye-USB noma localhost, futhi akukho ukufakwa kuhlu kwesitolo okungasuswa.
Uma uthole ukuqhathanisa kwethu okuthembekile kuwusizo futhi iNymchat iyona ofuna ukuyizama, Ukuqalisa kuthatha cishe umzuzu futhi ayikuceli lutho.