Tushen ilimi Fara a nan
Yadda Nymchat ya kwatanta
Nymchat ya auna da sauran manzanni goma sha uku, akan abubuwan da a zahiri sun bambanta a tsakaninsu. Inda mai gasa ya fi kyau, wannan shafin yana faɗin haka - kwatance cewa yana da marubucin lashe kowane jere ba kwatanta ba.
An fassara wannan shafin na inji don dacewa. Asalin Ingilishi shine sigar da ke aiki.
An bincika tare da takaddun kowane aikin a watan Agusta 2026. Duk waɗannan ƙa'idodin suna jigilar kaya sau da yawa, kuma da yawa daga cikin layuka da ke ƙasa su ne ainihin irin abubuwan da ke canzawa a cikin a saki. Idan wani jeri na musamman yana ɗaukar nauyi don shawarar ku, tabbatar da shi a kan aiwatar da kanta kafin ku dogara da shi.
A kallo
Encryption shine gungumomi na tebur akan wannan shafin: kusan komai anan yana yin ta ta tsohuwa, kuma Nymchat ya wuce mafi yawan - babu lambar waya, babu asusu, da nannade kyauta saƙonnin da relays ɗin da ke ɗauke da su ba za su iya karantawa ba kuma ba za su iya siffanta su ba. Inda filin a zahiri rabuwa ne me ke faruwa a lokacin da kayayyakin more rayuwa suka tafi. Kusan duk sanannen manzo da aka boye yana tsayawa ya mutu ba tare da intanet ba, saboda tsaron sa samfurin yana ɗaukan uwar garken da zai iya kaiwa. Hannun da ke ci gaba da aiki ba tare da daya ba a tarihi an biya shi ta hanyar kasancewa da ƙarancin fasali.
Shirya filin akan waɗannan tambayoyin guda biyu - nawa ne na manzo da kuke samu, da ko shi ya tsira daga hanyar sadarwa yana raguwa - ya bar kusurwa ɗaya kusan komai:
Yana yin komai, amma kawai yayin da intanet ya tashi
- Sigina
- Telegram
- Abun ciki
Duk abin da kuke tsammani daga aikace-aikacen taɗi, ana kawowa sabobin wani. Yanke haɗin kuma kowane ɗayan su babu komai allo.
Yana yin komai, kuma ya tsira daga grid yana sauka
- Nymchat
Rufaffen taɗi na rukuni, kira, kafofin watsa labarai da biyan kuɗi idan akwai hanyar sadarwa ce, kuma ragar Bluetooth a ƙasa don lokacin da babu - azaman a cikakken abokin aiki akan Android da iOS, kuma azaman ganye a cikin masu binciken Chromium.
Mai da hankali, kuma har yanzu yana buƙatar intanet
- SimpleX
- Zama
- Delta Chat
- XChat
- Vector
- Farin Surutu
Kowane daga cikin wadannan suna ba tare da wani abubuwa a cikin lissafi a karkashin - karkashin yawanci gwiwa na jiki, wasu lokacin da wani yanar gizo. Ba da yawa ne mai kyau masana'antu; dukkan su ba su ci gaba da zama dukan.
Mai da hankali, kuma ya tsira daga grid yana sauka
- Armada
- Briar
- Bitchat
Kowannensu yana da kyau a abin da yake yi, kuma babu wanda aka gina don zama kawai app akan wayarka. Briar da Bitchat ba su da kira; Armada yana da kira amma babu wani gini na iOS, kuma ragarsa yana aiki akan Android kawai.
"Does everything" a nan yana da wani musamman list, za a iya sarrafawa: encrypted group chats, one-to-one da kuma group audio / video calls, media sharing, da kuma wani native app a cikin Android da iOS - bar ga wani abu za ka yi a matsayin kawai messenger.
Wannan shi ne gaba dayan filin, kuma sauran shafin nan ne shaida a kan sa. Nymchat ba Manzo mafi sirri da aka taɓa ginawa - SimpleX yana da da'awar da'awar hakan, Farin Hayaniya yana da mafi kyawun rubutun rukunoni, kuma Sigina yana da shekaru na tantancewa Nymchat baya. The iƙirarin ya fi kunkuntar: ɗaya daga cikin waɗannan shine ke share wannan mashaya kuma har yanzu yana aiki lokacin hanyar sadarwa ta tafi.
Asalin shine sauran rabinsa. Tsohuwar Nymchat shine nym minted lokacin da ka buɗe app ɗin kuma a jefar da ku idan kun gama, tare da Yanayin fatalwa juya maɓallai da sunan Bluetooth tare da saƙonnin da ke share kansu a baya ka. Yawancin wannan jeri yana ba ku asusu ɗaya wanda ke biye da ku tsakanin ɗakuna da tsakanin shekaru. Nymchat yana ba ku damar faɗi wani abu a cikin taron jama'a ba tare da ya biyo ku gida ba.
Manzanni a cikin wannan kwatance
Masu fafatawa goma sha uku, waɗanda aka zaɓa saboda kowannensu yana da kyau a wani abu da Nymchat ya kamata amsa ga. Shahararren kawai ba shine ma'auni ba - idan ya kasance, wannan jerin zai kasance apps uku dogaye kuma basu da amfani sosai.
| App | Menene shi | Mafi kyawun hujjarsa |
|---|---|---|
| Nymchat | Abokin ciniki na Nostr tare da ragar Bluetooth a ƙasa | Cikakken manzo wanda baya tsayawa lokacin da hanyar sadarwa ta yi |
| Briar | Manzo-da-tsara akan Tor, Bluetooth, Wi-Fi da sandunan USB | Babu sabobin kwata-kwata, da binciken tsaro mai zaman kansa don nunawa |
| Armada | Rufaffen al'ummomin da ke cikin nau'in Discord akan Nostr, daga Akwatin Sabulu | Rukunin Bitchat a cikin cikakken aikace-aikacen al'umma, da ɗaukar nauyin kai har zuwa ƙasa |
| Bitchat | Tattaunawar raga ta Bluetooth tare da tashoshi na Nostr an kulle | Mafi kyawun magana na saƙon raga, an gwada shi yayin rufewa na gaske |
| Delta Chat | Manzo wanda ke hawa akan imel, tare da asusun taɗi mai yuwuwa | Yana gudana akan ababen more rayuwa waɗanda suka riga sun wanzu a ko'ina kuma ba za a iya rufe su ba |
| Abun ciki | Babban abokin ciniki na cibiyar sadarwar Matrix mai tarayya | Ƙungiyar da ke aiki a zahiri, kuma tana gadar kusan komai |
| Zama | Manzo mai karkatar da albasa akan hanyar sadarwar kumburin da ba ta da tushe | Babu lambar waya, kuma adireshin IP ɗin ku yana ɓoye daga mutanen da kuke magana da su |
| Sigina | Rufaffen manzo na tsakiya, wanda ƙungiyar sa-kai ke tafiyar da ita | Mafi kyawun duba bayanan sirri a cikin kasuwancin, da ka'idar kowa ya kwafi |
| SimpleX Chat | Messenger an gina shi akan layin saƙo na lokaci ɗaya maimakon asusun mai amfani | Babu mai gano mai amfani kowane iri - mafi ƙarfi labarin metadata anan |
| Telegram | Cloud Messenger tare da manyan kungiyoyi da tashoshi | Isar, goge, bots, da al'ummomi a cikin ɗaruruwan dubbai |
| Vector | Nostr manzo mai zaman kansa tare da AI akan na'urar da kuma ginanniyar walat | Rubutu da fassarar da ke gudana akan injin ku maimakon sabar |
| Meta's messenger, rufaffen ƙarshen-zuwa-ƙarshe ta tsohuwa | Duk wanda ka sani yana da shi | |
| XChat | Sake rubutawa na ƙungiyar 0xchat, tare da rukunin MLS "Circles" | Mafi kafaffen Manzo Nostr, da ɓoyayyen ƙungiyar MLS a cikin ƙa'idar jigilar kaya |
| Farin Surutu | Nostr messenger wanda aka gina akan MLS, ƙa'idar saƙon ƙungiyar IETF | Mafi ƙarfi rukunonin rukunoni akan Nostr, kuma yana da wuri - har yanzu alfa |
Aikace-aikacen akan wannan jerin mafi kusa da Nymchat shine Bitchat, kuma ba kusa ba wadanda suka zo na biyu. Su biyun suna raba ragar Bluetooth, suna raba tashoshi na geohash, kuma su An gada a matakin yarjejeniya - mai amfani da Bitchat da mai amfani da Nymchat iri ɗaya geohash suna cikin daki ɗaya, suna karanta saƙonnin juna, ba tare da app ɗin da ke yin komai ba na musamman. Babu wani abu kuma a nan da ke da wannan alaƙa da Nymchat. Manzannin Nostr - XChat, Vector, Armada, Farin Noise - raba hanyar sadarwa da saƙon sirri tsari, wanda ke sa su kwatanta mafi kusa don ɓoyayyen DMs da zaps, amma babu ɗayansu raga kuma babu wanda ke da dakuna na tushen wuri.
Ana kiran apps guda biyu da basu da alaƙa da suna XChat. Wanda anan ya fito ne daga aikin Nostr 0xchat — ba manzon X na ba Sunan guda ɗaya, wanda aka ƙaddamar a cikin Afrilu 2026 kuma bai raba kome da shi ba sai kalmar. Inda jere ke cewa "A cikin 0xchat", fasalin da aka aika a cikin tsohuwar 0xchat app da ɗan ƙasa sake rubuta har yanzu yana kama.
Siffa ta fasali
Tebura biyar, an haɗa su da tambayar da kowanne ɗaya ya amsa. Kowane ginshiƙi an rubuta su don haka Ee Amsar ita ce mai kyau - babu layuka inda koren tantanin halitta shine mummunan labari. The tebur suna gungurawa gefe akan kunkuntar allo, kuma sunan app yana tsayawa yayin da suke yi.
Shiga ciki
| Shiga ciki | Babu lambar waya | Babu asusun uwar garken | Identity shine maɓalli akan na'urarka | Buɗe ga baƙi | Imani na jifa |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nymchat | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee |
| Armada | Ee | Ee | Ee | A cikin al'ummai | A'a |
| Bitchat | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ephemeral ta tsohuwa |
| Briar | Ee | Ee | Ee | A'a | A'a |
| Delta Chat | Ee | An ƙirƙira muku | A'a | A'a | Adireshin da za a iya zubarwa |
| Abun ciki | Ee | A'a | A'a | A cikin dakunan jama'a | A'a |
| Zama | Ee | Ee | Ee | A bude kungiyoyin | A'a |
| Sigina | A'a | A'a | A'a | A'a | A'a |
| SimpleX | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ta hanyar haɗin gayyata | Yanayin incognito |
| Telegram | A'a | A'a | A'a | A cikin ƙungiyoyin jama'a | A'a |
| Vector | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | A'a |
| A'a | A'a | A'a | A'a | A'a | |
| Farin Surutu | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | A'a |
| XChat (0xchat) | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | A'a |
Sigina, Telegram da WhatsApp duk suna ɗaure asusunka zuwa lambar waya, wanda a galibi kasashe na nufin daure shi da ID na gwamnati. Sigina ya yi fiye da kowa don iyakancewa lalacewa - sunayen masu amfani suna nufin ba za ku taɓa mika lambar ga lamba ba, kuma tana ɓoye ta tsoho - amma har yanzu rajista yana buƙatar lambar aiki, kuma lambar ita ce asusu.
"Buɗe ga baƙi" shine layin da ke raba cibiyar sadarwar jama'a daga littafin adireshi. Briar, SimpleX da Delta Chat duk suna buƙatar ka fara musayar wani abu - lambar QR, a hanyar haɗi, adireshi - wanda yake da kyau ga sirri kuma mara amfani don shiga cikin daki da kuma gano abin da ke faruwa. Nymchat's ephemeral nym shine maɓalli wanda aka samar a wannan lokacin ka bude app; gani Halayen Ephemeral, kuma Yanayin fatalwa ga juyi juyi cewa shima yana canza abin da rediyon Bluetooth ɗin ku ke talla.
Tsayawa
| Cibiyar sadarwa | Yana aiki ba tare da intanet ba | Tashoshi na jama'a | Tashoshin da aka ɗaure zuwa wuri | Kuna zabar sabobin | Rayayye masu yin sa |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nymchat | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee |
| Armada | Android kawai | Ee | A'a | Ee | Ee |
| Bitchat | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee |
| Briar | Ee | A'a | A'a | Babu sabobin kwata-kwata | Ee |
| Delta Chat | A'a | Watsawa kawai | A'a | Ee | Ee |
| Abun ciki | A'a | Ee | A'a | Ee | Ee |
| Zama | A'a | Ee | A'a | Hanyar sadarwar node | Mai yiwuwa |
| Sigina | A'a | A'a | A'a | A'a | A'a |
| SimpleX | A'a | Ta hanyar haɗin gayyata | A'a | Ee | Ee |
| Telegram | A'a | Ee | A'a | A'a | A'a |
| Vector | A'a | A'a | A'a | Ee | Ee |
| A'a | Watsawa kawai | A'a | A'a | A'a | |
| Farin Surutu | A'a | A'a | A'a | Ee | Ee |
| XChat (0xchat) | A'a | Ee | A'a | Ee | Ee |
Wannan shine tebur Nymchat akwai don, kuma wasu apps guda uku suna amsa shi. Briar yana ɗauka saƙonni ta Bluetooth, Wi-Fi da sandunan USB. Bitchat mesh ne na Bluetooth da farko kuma komai na biyu. Armada yana jigilar tarin ragamar Android na Bitchat a cikin nasa app, a kunne Android.
Nymchat yana raba tsarin ragar sa tare da Bitchat da gangan: ƙa'idodin biyu sun haɗu da ɗakuna ɗaya kuma relay don juna, wanda ke sa cibiyar sadarwar layi ta fi girma ga duka biyun. Yana aiki akan Android da iOS a matsayin cikakken takwarorinsu, kuma a cikin masu binciken Chromium a matsayin ganye mai iya karba da aikawa amma ba tallata kanta. Duba Raba raga tare da Bitchat kuma Me gudu a ina.
Rukunin ƙarshe ya cancanci karantawa a hankali. Sigina ba riba ce mai kyau tare da kyakkyawan rikodin kuma a'a niyyar zuwa ko'ina, amma Sigina ba tare da sabar Sigin ba komai bane. Nostr relays, Matrix homeservers, SimpleX relays da talakawa mail sabar duk software kowa na iya aiki, don haka "kungiyar ta rufe" da "Network ya mutu" abubuwa ne daban-daban. Delta Taɗi yana da mafi ƙarfi sigar wannan gardama akan jeri: tana tafiya akan imel, wanda ba haka bane zuwa ko'ina.
Abin da cibiyar sadarwa ke iya gani
| Keɓantawa | Rufaffen saƙon sirri ta tsohuwa | Rukunin tattaunawar rukuni | Sirrin gaba | Musanyar maɓalli na bayan-ƙira | An ɓoye mai aikawa da mai karɓa | Saƙonnin batattu | Binciken mai zaman kansa ya buga |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nymchat | Ee | Ee | A'a | ML-KEM-768 | Groups; PMs hanya | Ee | Tukuna |
| Armada | Ee | Concord | Ba a bayyana ba | A'a | Sauke kawai | A'a | A'a |
| Bitchat | Ee | Tashoshi na jama'a ne | Ee | A'a | Wani bangare | Ee | A'a |
| Briar | Ee | Ee | Ee | A'a | Ee | A'a | Ee |
| Delta Chat | Ee | Ee | Autocrypt v2 | A'a | Wani bangare | Ee | Ee |
| Abun ciki | Ee | Ee | Ee | A'a | A'a | Kowane daki | Ee |
| Zama | Ee | Ee | An cire | A'a | Ee | Ee | Ee |
| Sigina | Ee | Ee | Ee | PQXDH | Mai aikawa da aka rufe | Ee | Ee |
| SimpleX | Ee | Ee | Ee | zafi761 | Ee | Ee | Ee |
| Telegram | Hirar sirri kawai | A'a | Hirar sirri kawai | A'a | A'a | Ee | A'a |
| Vector | Ee | Al'umma suna ci gaba | Ba a bayyana ba | A'a | Sauke kawai | A'a | A'a |
| Ee | Ee | Ee | A'a | A'a | Ee | Rufe tushe | |
| Farin Surutu | Ee | MLS | MLS | A'a | Ee | A'a | Ee |
| XChat (0xchat) | Ee | MLS | MLS | A'a | Sauke kawai | A'a | A'a |
The post-quantum column ne game da wani takardar sha'awa: mai ban sha'awar da aka rubuta lantarki a yau don ƙirƙirar shi shekaru da suka wuce, a lokacin da wani quantum kwamfuta za a iya shigar da classic Key Agreement kowane app a nan rufe. Duk da haka, ba tare da shi don haɓaka lissafi daga abin da za a iya karanta shi a yanzu, kuma ba shi ne ba tare da lissafi - kawai don takardar kebantawa. Tare da aikace-aikace a cikin wannan lissafi ya gabatarwa, kuma kowane hudu ya ƙirƙirar wani post-quantum key encapsulation a cikin lissafi don haka cewa karanta wani lissafi yana da karantawa duka biyuSignal - farko, tare da PQXDH, da kuma bayan da aka gabatar da post-quantum ratchet - da kuma SimpleX, tare da sntrup761 a cikin biyu ratchet, Ƙaddamar two share secrets a cikin daya key. Nymchat Wasanni Yanzu: NIP-44 lissafi ne daidai da shi ne da yaushe a cikin ChaCha20-Poly1305, keyed daga wani ML-KEM-768 encapsulation - NIST standard, FIPS 203. Ƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙ Rufaffen bayanan ƙididdiga. Wannan ginshiƙi ne wanda zai tsufa da sauri, kuma "A'a" a nan yana nufin "ba a aika kamar wannan rubutun", ba "ba" ba.
Tare da ƙarfi mai yawa da ƙarfi, da na farko daga su ne Nymchat.
Nymchat ba tare da wani hadin gwiwaNIP-44 ya ƙirƙirar da hankali daga cikin biyu long-term identity keys, da kuma ML-KEM key da post-quantum layer encapsulates a shi ne long-lived kuma, don haka kowane wanda ya samu nsec
Plus your nympq1… code, ga post-quantum layer - za a iya karanta kowane kayayyakin da aka sauke da waɗanda keys ko da yaushe, ba kawai waɗanda m. PM yana ɓacewa (sirrin gaba) a Privacy & Safety ne wani NIP-40 matsa lissafi ba da relays don rufe lissafi bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin bayanin. Telegram ba za a cripte ƙarfi zuwa ƙarfi, idan ba ka kafa musamman a Secret Chat, wanda shi ne kawai daya zuwa daya kuma ba ya saita tsakanin na'urorinku - don haka a karkashin kowane Telegram tallace-tallace, da kuma
kowane Ƙungiyar Telegram, tana zaune ana iya karantawa akan sabar Telegram.
Zama da gangan ya faɗi sirrin gaba lokacin da ya motsa daga Siginar
yarjejeniya, ma'ana maɓalli na dogon lokaci da aka sace yana fallasa tarihin gaba ɗaya maimakon 'yan kwanan nan
saƙonni; aikin ya ce sigar yarjejeniya ta gaba za ta dawo da shi.
Delta Chat ya gaji rashin bayanan sirri na OpenPGP, kuma ya ce
Autocrypt v2 zai gyara shi.
The metadata column sanyaya, ga Nymchat, tsakanin biyu sanyaya. Kowane albarkatun albarkatun da aka ƙirƙirƙirar da ƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙirƙira Tuntube 1. What differs is the recipient. A waya ya ƙunshi daya a cikin p tag, a cikin m, saboda wannan tag shi ne kamar yadda abokan ciniki ya samu lissafi - amma a
Ƙungiyar wannan tag yana ƙirƙirar wani rotating per-member key ko da yaushe na m, don haka ƙirƙirar jiki na jiki ba za a nuna a matsayin N wraps zuwa N pubkeys a lokacin da wani relay ba ya sa kowace.
Yadda ɓoyayyen rukuni ke aikia cikin
Ƙananan tallace-tallace, akwai wani abu don sauke: shiryawa da aka gabatar da hakkin yanar gizo na peer, don haka relays ganin wanda ya samu da kira kada.
Kowane abokan ciniki na Nostr a nan wanda ya samarwa a kan NIP-17 na'ura mai tsanani yana da wannan wani-to-da-da-da-da-daban, da haka da Armada, Vector da XChat ya karanta "tallace-tallace kawai" ma - girma a cikin jiki na jiki ne na Nymchat, ba da jiki na protocol. White Noise ba da shi da wani daban-daban: ta MLS kayayyakin ya zo a kan wani na'ura mai tsanani fiye da kowane ma'aikata. Kuma shi ne m SimpleX ba a kowace, a kowace jiki, saboda yana ba da wutar lantarki ba tare da wani alama don karanta a farko.
Rukunin ƙarshe shine wanda Nymchat ya rasa, kuma ya ɓace ƙasa a wannan shekara. Briar ya kasance An duba ta Cure53, SimpleX ta Trail of Bits, Farin Noise ta Mafi Karancin Hukuma a cikin Afrilu 2026, da Sigina, Matrix da Delta Chat akai-akai ta kamfanoni da yawa. Nymchat har yanzu ba a yi wani abu ba dubawa na ɓangare na uku. Abin da yake bayarwa a maimakon shi ne cewa dukan abu shine bude tushen da kuma Ginin da aka aika yana iya sakewa, saboda haka zaku iya bincika binary akan tushen da kanku - gani Gina mai maimaitawa. Wannan ba a maye gurbin bincike, kuma wannan shafin ba zai yi kamar yana ba.
Nymchat ta Ba a rufaffen tashoshi na jama'a, kuma ba Bitchat's ba. Wannan shi ne zane - ɗakin jama'a kawai wasu mutane za su iya karantawa ba ɗakin jama'a ba ne - amma yana nufin duk abin da kuka aika zuwa tasha lamari ne da ba a bayyana ba a fili relays. Rukunin da ke sama game da saƙonnin sirri ne da tattaunawar rukuni. Duba Tashoshi iri biyu.
Abin da za ku iya yi a zahiri
| Siffofin | Kira daya-da-daya | Kiran rukuni | Hirar rukuni | Mai jarida da fayiloli | Biyan walƙiya | Gina-in mataimakin | Fassara a wuri |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nymchat | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee |
| Armada | Ee | Dakunan murya | Ee | Ee | Ba a bayyana ba | A'a | A'a |
| Bitchat | A'a | A'a | Tashoshi na jama'a | Hotuna da bayanan murya | A'a | A'a | A'a |
| Briar | A'a | A'a | Ee | Hotuna kawai | A'a | A'a | A'a |
| Delta Chat | Ee | A'a | Ee | Ee | A'a | A'a | A'a |
| Abun ciki | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | A'a | A'a | A'a |
| Zama | Ee | A'a | Ee | Ee | A'a | A'a | A'a |
| Sigina | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | A'a | A'a | A'a |
| SimpleX | Ee | A'a | Ee | Ee | A'a | A'a | A'a |
| Telegram | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | A'a | Bots na ɓangare na uku | Ee |
| Vector | A'a | A'a | Al'umma suna ci gaba | Ee | Wallet da aka gina a ciki | Kan na'ura | Kan na'ura |
| Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | A'a | Meta AI | Ee | |
| Farin Surutu | A'a | A'a | Ee | Ee | A'a | A'a | A'a |
| XChat (0xchat) | A cikin 0xchat | A'a | Ee | Ee | A cikin 0xchat | A'a | A'a |
Briar, Bitchat, Vector da Farin Hayaniya sune inda "mayar da hankali" rabin makircin ya zo daga, kuma layin da ya sanya su akwai ginshiƙin kira: babu ɗayan huɗun da zai sanya a kiran murya ko bidiyo. Ba ƙarancin fasali ba ne a wani wuri. Bitchat yanzu yana ɗauka rufaffiyar hotuna da bayanan murya akan ragar kanta - matsala ce mai wahala fiye da ita sauti akan jinkirin, rabawa, radiyo mai amfani da baturi, da rata akan Nymchat wanda ke da rufe.
Zance kai tsaye shine abin da ya rage. Kira yana buƙatar hanyar duplex tare da ƙarancin jinkiri, wanda a Multi-hop Bluetooth mesh ba zai iya ba ku ba, don haka Nymchat yana ɗaukar kira akan hanyar sadarwa kuma ya koma ga rubutu da raga idan babu. Wannan shine bambanci tsakanin app wanda ke ci gaba da aiki a cikin duhu kuma wanda kuma za ku yi amfani da shi a ranar Talata.
Rukunin mataimaka yana buƙatar faɗakarwa mai nuni nesa da Nymchat. Meta AI mataimaki ne na gaske an gina shi cikin WhatsApp, kuma Vector's yana gudana a kan na'urar ku - Yin raɗaɗi kwafi da fassarar gida, wanda shine ingantaccen labarin sirri na gaske fiye da Nymbot ta. Abin da Nymbot ke ba ku a maimakon haka shine mataimaki da zaku iya amfani da shi a tashar jama'a ba tare da bayyana kanku ba, a cikin tattaunawa ta sirri wanda aka nannade kyauta kamar kowane zance. Duba Hirar sirri - da bayanin kula cewa har yanzu ma'aikacin bot zai iya karanta abin da kuka aika, wanda shine gaskiya ga kowane ɓangaren uwar garken mataimaki a kan wannan jerin.
Inda yake gudana, da wanda ke tafiyar da shi
| Dandalin | Android | iOS | Desktop ko browser | Ana iya shigarwa ba tare da kantin kayan aiki ba | Yana gudana daga kwafin da kuke ɗaukar nauyin kanku | Bude tushen | Babu sabis na Google da ake buƙata |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nymchat | Ee | TestFlight | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee |
| Armada | Ee | Browser kawai | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee |
| Bitchat | Ee | Ee | A'a | Android kawai | A'a | Ee | Ee |
| Briar | Ee | A'a | Ee | Ee | A'a | Ee | Ee |
| Delta Chat | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | A'a | Ee | Ee |
| Abun ciki | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee |
| Zama | Ee | Ee | Ee | Android kawai | A'a | Ee | Ee |
| Sigina | Ee | Ee | Ee | Android kawai | A'a | Ee | Ee |
| SimpleX | Ee | Ee | Ee | Android kawai | A'a | Ee | Ee |
| Telegram | Ee | Ee | Ee | Android kawai | Sabar Telegram kawai | Abokin ciniki kawai | A'a |
| Vector | Ee | A'a | Ee | Ee | A'a | Ee | Ee |
| Ee | Ee | Ee | A'a | A'a | A'a | A'a | |
| Farin Surutu | Ee | Ee | Ee | Ee | A'a | Ee | Ee |
| XChat (0xchat) | Ee | Ee | A cikin 0xchat | Ee | A'a | Ee | Ee |
Gina iOS na Nymchat yana kan TestFlight maimakon App Store, wanda gaskiya ne "wani bangare" - yana shigarwa akan kowane iPhone, amma ta hanyar tashar beta ta Apple. Briar da Vector ba shi da gina iOS kwata-kwata, kuma Briar ya ce dalilin da ya sa a sarari: iOS ba zai bari bango ba Tsarin yana kiyaye haɗin kai-da-tsara a raye kamar yadda gine-ginensa ke buƙata. Nymchat ya shiga siga mai sauƙi na bango ɗaya, wanda shine dalilin da yasa sanarwar iOS ta zo a makare yayin aikace-aikacen an dakatar da shi. Duba Me gudu a ina.
Rukunin da ya cancanci tsayawa akan shi shine game da ɗaukar nauyin kwafin ku, saboda shi ya bayyana yadda a zahiri manzo yake mutuwa a cikin ƙasa. Ba cryptanalysis - delisting. Apple da Google maki guda ne na shaƙa, gwamnatoci sun san shi, kuma an cire app daga duka biyun Stores sun tafi kusan duk wanda ke amfani da shi.
Nymchat ta yanar gizo app ne bayyananne HTML, CSS da JavaScript module tare da babu matakin ginawa. Ku bauta masa daga kowane tsayayyen runduna, kebul sanda ko localhost kuma shine duka app - yarjejeniya iri ɗaya, relays iri ɗaya, cibiyar sadarwa iri ɗaya kamar yadda wayar ke ginawa, ana iya shigar da ita zuwa allon gida daga mai binciken. Babu komai yarda kuma babu abin da zai sauke. Ana iya toshe yanki; fayil wanda dubban mutane ba za a iya buga su ba.
Wasu biyu za su iya yin wannan, kuma dukansu sun cancanci yabo. Element Web ya kasance koyaushe mai son kai, kuma Armada ya fi kowa a nan - yana rubuta yadda ake gudanar da aikin aikace-aikacen gidan yanar gizo, hanyar sadarwar jama'a da uwar garken murya da kanka. Sauran goma sha ɗaya ba za su iya: Sigina, Zama, SimpleX, Briar, Delta Chat, Vector, Farin Noise, Bitchat da XChat sune aikace-aikacen asali ba tare da ginin burauzar ba, abokin ciniki na gidan yanar gizo na Telegram yana magana da Telegram kawai, kuma Yanar Gizo na WhatsApp yana buƙatar waya don haɗawa da.
Wannan ya cancanci zama daidai game da shi maimakon overlling. Kwafin wanda ya shiryar da kansa Har yanzu abokin ciniki yana buƙatar gudun ba da sanda don isa ga duk wanda ya wuce iyakar Bluetooth - amma relays ne Hakanan software kowa zai iya aiki, akwai daruruwan jama'a, kuma Nymchat yana ba ku damar nuna duk abin da kuke so. Dole ne a tantance abokin ciniki da cibiyar sadarwar daban, kuma ba shi da mai shi da zai ba da odar.
Abin da kawai Nymchat yake yi
Ba wani abu ɗaya da yake yi anan, kuma huɗu waɗanda ɗimbin sauran ƙa'idodin ke rabawa.
- raga a kan kowane dandali da yake jigilar kaya a kai. Briar da Bitchat duka biyun gudu ba tare da ababen more rayuwa ba, kuma Bitchat yanzu yana ɗaukar hotuna akan sa - amma ba zai yi kira. Nymchat shine kawai app anan inda yanayin layi ya koma baya a cikin cikakken manzo maimakon duka samfurin, kuma yana lalata a matsayin cikakken ɗan'uwa akan Android da iOS kuma azaman ganye a cikin masu binciken Chromium. Bakin baki baya duba wanne waya ka siya.
- Dakunan jama'a suna magana ta wuri. Tashar geohash tana kunna kowane murabba'i Duniya cikin dakin hira wanda baya buƙatar mai shi, babu mai gudanarwa kuma babu gayyata - duk wanda na'urarsa ta yanke shawarar zuwa wannan filin ya riga ya kasance a ciki. Bitchat yana da wannan kuma, kuma biyu apps raba da dakuna. Babu wanda yake da wani abu makamancinsa. Duba Tashoshi na Geohash.
- Kuɗin da ke motsawa a cikin zance. Walƙiya ta zabura akan saƙo ko bayanin martaba, daidaita takwarorinsu don yin kallo a cikin daƙiƙa na ɗan ƙaramin ɗari. Wannan ba a Nymchat keɓaɓɓen akan Nostr - XChat yana da zaps kuma Vector yana jigilar jaka - amma yana ko'ina kuma akan wannan jerin, kuma Nymchat shine kawai app ɗin da ke da shi kusa da a raga Duba Aika zap.
- Rufaffen bayanan ƙididdiga akan Nostr. Nymchat ta masu zaman kansu bayanai da jima'i jima'i ya rubuta tsari na NIP-44 ciphertext a cikin biyu, ML-KEM-768 layer, don haka lantarki da aka rubuta a yau ba za a iya karanta da wani gaba da kwantum kwamfutarci. Wannan ba ne wani Nymchat inji - Signal da SimpleX ya zama a nan na farko, kuma ya ce a kansa - amma a Nostr shi ne Nymchat kawai. XChat, Vector, Armada, White Noise da kuma kowane sauran Nostr abokan ciniki a nan da secp256k1 da kuma wani abu. Yana ba da bukatar wani setup da kuma wani key exchange za ka iya ganin: biyu Nymchat masu amfani zauna shi automatically, da kuma rubutu zuwa Bitchat ko m-Nostr abokan ciniki zauna Rufaffen bayanan ƙididdiga.
- Tattaunawar rukuni waɗanda ke ɓoye membobinsu. Daidaitaccen kyauta na kunshe leaks jerin membobinsu - N nannade zuwa N pubkeys a lokaci guda shine zamantakewa jadawali ko da yake babu abin da ya rage. Nymchat tana juya maɓallan mai karɓa don haka tsarin ya yi ba form. Farin Hayaniyar da XChat sun isa dukiya ɗaya ta hanyar MLS maimakon; ukun daga cikin mu kadai ne a kan wannan jerin a samun shi kwata-kwata. Duba Yadda ɓoyayyen rukuni ke aiki.
Inda sauran suka fi karfi
Kowane ɗayan waɗannan dalili ne na gaske don zaɓar wani abu dabam, kuma babu ɗayansu da zai kasance gardama tafi nan.
| App | Abin da ya fi kyau |
|---|---|
| Sigina | Cryptography cewa ya dace da masu sana'a a kan shekaru da suka wuce, ciki har da dubban ratchet - yanzu post-quantum - wanda ya ba da hankali ga Nymchat ba. Idan takardar kebantawa model ne a kasar actor kuma za ka so mafi reviewed abu a samuwa, shi ne yanzu Signal, kuma shi ne ba a gudu. |
| SimpleX | Mafi kyawun labarin metadata fiye da na Nymchat. Nymchat yana ba ku maɓalli mara suna; SimpleX yana ba cibiyar sadarwa ba mai ganowa don daidaitawa kwata-kwata, har ma da a bazuwar daya. Idan boye cewa kuna tattaunawa al'amura fiye da abinda ke ciki, SimpleX yayi nasara. |
| Farin Surutu | Ƙarfin ɓoyayyiyar rukunoni fiye da na Nymchat, akan hanyar sadarwa ɗaya. Duka apps suna dawowa bayan an lalata na'urar - Nymchat's maɓallan karɓa masu juyawa daidai suke wannan tsarin - amma MLS ya sanya shi garantin yarjejeniya. |
| Armada | Mafi tsayayyen labari mai ɗaukar nauyin kai akan wannan jeri: ƙa'idar yanar gizo, da gudun ba da sandar al'umma da sabar muryar LiveKit duk an rubuta su don aiki kayan aikin ku. Ka'idar al'umma ce mai siffar Discord maimakon a Messenger, kuma yana ɗaukar ragar Bluetooth akan Android. |
| XChat | Haɗin kai tare da Nymchat shine mafi girma akan wannan jerin - Maɓallan Nostr, zaps, rufaffiyar rukunoni - kuma yana yin rukunin rabin tare da MLS maimakon fiye da juyawa kyauta nade. Idan kuna son abin da Nymchat ke bayarwa akan layi kuma kar ku bukatar raga, yana da gaskiya fada. |
| Briar | Babu sabobin a ko'ina a cikin ƙira, har ma da na zaɓi, da wani da aka buga Cure53 duba. Nymchat har yanzu yana kaiwa ga sake kunnawa lokacin da intanet ke wanzu; Briar baya yi. |
| Bitchat | Karami, mafi sauƙi da sauƙi don tunani akai. Ƙananan siffofi shine tsaro dukiya, kuma a cikin ingantacciyar hanyar rufe app ɗin da aka cire wanda ke yin abu ɗaya zabi ne mai karewa. |
| Delta Chat | Yana hawa kan imel, don haka yana aiki ta hanyar ababen more rayuwa waɗanda suka wanzu a ciki kowace ƙasa da cewa babu kamfani ɗaya da zai iya kashewa. Babu wani abu kuma a nan yana da hanyar sadarwa da ta kafa. |
| Vector | AI yana aiki akan na'urarka. Rubutu da fassarar ba su taɓa barin daga inji, wanda ya fi aike su zuwa Nymbot - kuma shi ya tabbatar da fasalin ba dole ne ya biya ku sirrin sirri ba. |
| Abun ciki | Tarayyar tare da ainihin turawa a baya - gwamnatoci da jami'o'i suna gudanar da nasu uwar garken gida - da gadoji zuwa IRC, Slack, Rikici da sauransu. Idan kana buƙatar mallakar uwar garken, wannan shine balagagge zaɓi. |
| Zama | Ana kunna albasa ta tsohuwa, don haka adireshin IP ɗin ku yana ɓoye daga hanyar sadarwar ba tare da kun saita komai ba. Nymchat na iya yin hakan ta hanyar sa wakili na sirriamma wannan saitin ne, kuma saitin abu ne da mutane suke mantawa. |
| Telegram | Al'ummomi a sikelin babu wani abu da ke gabatowa anan, yanayin yanayin bot tare da shekaru na aiki a cikinsa, da mafi kyawun ƙwarewar na'urori da yawa na kowane app akan wannan shafi. |
| Kowa ya riga ya samu. Manzo da ba wanda ka sani ba zai shigar da kariya ba ba kome ba, kuma wannan ba ƙaramin batu ba ne - shine dalilin da ya fi tsaro manzanni sun kasa. |
Wanne ya kamata ku yi amfani da shi
Gaskiya: fiye da ɗaya. Waɗannan kyauta ne, kuma ba su kashe komai don ci gaba da shigar da su ranar kana bukatar su.
- Kuna buƙatar mafi ƙaƙƙarfan bayanan sirri da aka bita. Sigina, kuma saka Nymchat kusa da shi don lokacin da cibiyar sadarwa ta tafi.
- Kuna buƙatar hanyar sadarwar don kar ku san akwai. SimpleX.
- Kuna cikin zanga-zangar, biki, filin wasa, ko kuma inda intanet ya kasance yanke. Nymchat ko Bitchat, ko Armada idan kowa yana cikin Android - kuma yana da mahimmanci fiye da yadda kuke tunani wanda, saboda suna gudanar da raga iri ɗaya.
- Kuna son app guda ɗaya don tattaunawar yau da kullun wanda shima ya tsira a baki. Nymchat. Wannan shi ne dalilin da ya sa ya wanzu.
- Kuna son mafi kyawun ɓoyayyen rukuni akan Nostr. Farin Hayaniya, wanda yanzu yana da duba don mayar da shi, ko XChat idan kuna son samun zaps da kira a cikin app iri daya.
- Kuna buƙatar gudanar da abubuwan more rayuwa da kanku, ƙarƙashin manufofin ku. Abun da ke tare da uwar garken gida naku, Armada tare da relay ɗin ku da sabar murya, ko Delta Yi taɗi tare da sabar saƙon ku.
- Kuna tsammanin za a dakatar da app ɗin a inda kuke zama. Nymchat. Gidan yanar gizo app babban fayil ne na fayiloli ba tare da matakin ginawa ba, don haka yana gudana daga madaidaicin runduna, sandar USB ko localhost, kuma babu jerin shagunan da za a cire.
Idan kun sami kwatancenmu na gaskiya yana taimakawa kuma Nymchat shine wanda kuke son gwadawa, Farawa yana ɗaukar kusan minti ɗaya kuma baya tambayar ku komai.